In July 2025, Molly and Paul Fracasso took a leap of faith and bought a home in Charlotte, N.C., without ever setting foot inside.

At the time, the 29-year-old couple was living over 700 miles away in the heart of Miami, scrolling through listings and dreaming of a place to plant roots.

Surprisingly, one particular home caught their eye, so they sent a close friend – who also happened to be a trusted real estate agent – to tour it on their behalf.

The moment their friend entered the home, she called them and said, “This house feels like you.” That one sentence was all the confirmation they needed.

“We made an offer without even seeing it in person,” Molly tells PEOPLE exclusively. “The signs were everywhere. It just felt right.”

The 2,500-square-foot house has four bedrooms and three bathrooms, but what stood out most to Molly was how much it resembled her childhood home.

“What immediately struck us were the cozy sunroom and the koi pond in the backyard — it reminded me so much of the home I grew up in,” she explains.

“My dad spent years creating a backyard oasis with a pond where we spent many evenings as a family. This house felt like a mirror of that experience.”

The Fracassos also weren’t looking for something ordinary, but rather something with “character, history, and a soul.” Much to their surprise, they found exactly that — and more.

Their new home was filled with charming old-school touches, including an attic fan and functional heat lamps in the primary shower – all installed and meticulously maintained by the previous owners, Faith Barnshaw, 81, and her husband, John Barnshaw III, 80.

“John and Faith lived here for 45 years. They raised their kids here and later made countless memories with their grandkids,” Molly reveals. “You can feel that history in every corner of the house.”

John, an electrical engineer, brought thoughtful touches to every part of the home – from the labeled tools in the workshop to the neatly organized electrical system.

He even left behind binders filled with renovation records, manuals and service contacts; everything the next owners might need.

“The house wasn’t just well-maintained – it was cherished,” Molly emphasizes.

When purchasing the home, the Fracassos never expected such a warm welcome from the Barnshaws – let alone the close friendship that would grow from it.

“One of the most touching early moments was when we came by before closing and found John knee-deep in the koi pond, rearranging rocks and topping off the water — just to make sure it looked perfect for us,” Molly recalls. “That moment said everything about the kind of person he is.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Ever since moving in, the 80-year-old has been more than happy to help Molly and Paul around the house as they settle in.

“He’s filled with pride and enthusiasm. The moment he steps onto the property, you can see how much he loves this home,” Molly says. “He’s eager to share tips, tricks and the little details that make this place run smoothly.”

Living only three-quarters of a mile away, in a nearby apartment complex, makes it easy for John to stop by when he is needed, eagerly offering a helping hand for any and all work that needs to be done around the house.

“Any time we have a question, he doesn’t just tell us what to do – he shows up and walks Paul through it, step by step,” Molly says. “It truly feels like he’s training Paul to take over a home he poured his heart into. It’s been a beautiful transition.”

In a viral TikTok with 1.8 million views, John is seen showing Paul how to use the pond vacuum he left behind.

“He wanted to make sure we knew exactly how to maintain the pond the way he had for so many years,” Molly shares.

Beyond restoring the floors, painting a few cabinets and swapping out a couple of light fixtures, the Fracassos have kept the home almost exactly as it was.

“The bones are incredible, and the spirit of the house is something we don’t want to lose,” Molly admits. “While we’re adding our own touches over time, we feel honored to continue what the Barnshaws built.”

When asked why the Barnshaws sold their home, John says, despite their “mixed feelings,” they “knew that the time had come to make a change.”

After handing over the keys to their cherished home, the elderly couple was set on making Molly and Paul’s move into their first house feel special – and that is exactly what they did.

“Since sharing our story on TikTok, people have commented that we didn’t just buy a house – we gained a grandpa. And it’s true,” Molly shares.

“The outpouring of support and connection from people online has been incredible. It shows how much the world is craving kindness, tradition and community. The Barnshaws embody all of that.”