Nara Sushi Party Tray

Let’s be honest: The bar for supermarket sushi is low. The rice is often hard and dry, and that’s the least of your concerns if the fish isn’t fresh. So imagine my surprise — and sheer delight — when I sampled the vibrant 40-piece Nara Sushi Party Tray. It’s dazzling and includes upgrades to fan favorites, like California crunch rolls topped with kani (imitation crab), spicy aioli, and crispy fried onions for snap.

The standout is the spicy mango tuna roll, wrapped in a thin layer of sweet mango — the kind you rarely see outside a sushi restaurant. Every piece is made fresh daily, and the craftsmanship and care rival what you’d find at good sushi bars.

Kobe Sushi Roll Party Tray

If you’re a fan of nigiri, the hand-pressed style of sushi topped with a piece of fish, the Kobe Sushi Roll Party Tray is right up your alley.

Featuring three different types of nigiri — ebi (shrimp), salmon, and wild-caught tuna — this tray is guaranteed to wow any crowd. It also includes fresh handrolls like classic California rolls and a tempura shrimp roll for extra crunch, totaling 42 pieces.

Akita Sushi Roll Party Tray

The Akita Sushi Roll Party Tray is the largest sushi party tray in this selection, featuring 44 pieces of sushi that include both hand-rolled and nigiri varieties.

This particular arrangement offers three different kinds of California rolls — a spicy California roll for added kick, a California crunch roll for texture, and a classic California roll. Great for large parties or gatherings, the Akita has something for everyone.

Praline Pecans

Tossed in butter, brown sugar, and salt, the Member’s Mark Praline Pecans are a secret weapon in the kitchen for punching up charcuterie boards and salads or topping yogurt and overnight oats. Leave a tub on my desk, and my willpower vanishes because not eating them by the handful is, frankly, impossible.

Pineapple Jalapeño Popper Dip

Sweet and spicy — aka “swicy” — is my favorite combo. Although this Pineapple Jalapeño Popper Dip is rich, it doesn’t feel heavy because the pineapple pieces add bright, fruity acidity, and the heat builds slowly. It’s an easy, effortless win for any spread like holiday parties, game day, or solo snacking.

Tandoori Style Naan Bites

Fresh naan is always a win, but these mini rounds are an easy (and delicious) stand-in. Baked in a tandoor-style oven, Tandoori Style Naan Bites deliver smoky char and a soft, chewy bite reminiscent of the full-size flatbread.

Pile on dips and spreads, or serve alongside your favorite fall soup or fragrant curry. For the best texture, warm them for a few seconds in the microwave for an extra-tender finish.

Stags’ Leap Cabernet Sauvignon

In Napa Valley, Cab is king. This juicy Cabernet Sauvignon — from Stags’ Leap Wineryowned by Treasury Wine Estates — layers jammy red fruit with sweet-tart black plum and herbaceous bay leaf. Rich and full-bodied without feeling heavy, it’s a smart host gift — or the perfect pour after a long day.

Cinnamon Honey Butter

Sam’s Club Cinnamon Honey Butterwhich debuted in July 2025, quickly earned cult status as a delicious “dupe” of the cinnamon-flecked butter served with Texas Roadhouse’s famous yeast rolls.

Rich and creamy, the spread has a pleasant, not-too-sweet flavor with warming cinnamon spice throughout. It’s also made without seed oils. Beyond rolls, spread it on toast, melt it atop pancakes, or drizzle it over sweet potatoes this Thanksgiving.

Charcuterie Entertainment Tray

At any gathering, all eyes are on the charcuterie board. But puzzling one together — especially at the last minute — is time-consuming. Luckily, the packed Charcuterie Entertainment Tray comes preassembled with Italian cured meats such as peppery hot soppressata and porky Genoa salami, plus three cheeses (two semisoft, one semihard).

A briny Greek olive medley, jammy fig spread, and plenty of multigrain crackers tie it all together. Transfer everything to your own board and no one will be the wiser that you spent less time and saved money on a show-stopping centerpiece.